Discussion about this post

User's avatar
François Arsenault's avatar

You again missed my point. Some 2 million Israeli citizens are from Arab origin. This population is presumably not Jewish. Have you ever looked into the ways the Israeli government is treating these people? To what extent the Israeli government has established a legal system to systematically discriminate against 20 percent of its population? Please have a look before responding.

Expand full comment
François Arsenault's avatar

Dear Eduardo,

I have read more than once your articles on « what if » and « why ». I have many problems with both. Your « what if » are not random but rather attempts at applying « blame » to history. We could all exercise our « what if » as selective as you seem to do. Only two examples, maybe. What if the lead-up to the creation of Israel, and its unilateral creation without effective consideration for Palestinian sovereignty been thought out differently? What if the massive influx of Jews in Palestine had been managed te take into account the occupation of some 700,000 Palestinians that were brutally depossessed of their land, dwellings, commerces and social institutions. A second « what if » concerns the fate of Palestinian citizens of Israel (PCIs). What if the 2 million PCIs were treated as first class citizens along first class Jews of Israel? What if PCIs were not specifically targeted in law by multiple restrictions on where they may reside, what history their children may be exposed to, etc? What if Israel had put into law that it is a republic rather than a Jewish state, creating a first citizens population and a second citizens population of 2 million.

And now the why! I will obviously not go through your « why’s « . This being said , you know very well why many of the issues raised , and how they are being dealt with, are not on the six o’clock news! Many of them may only be dealt through silent diplomacy. Secondly, others cannot be resolved through outright instinctive retributions or military actions. If one were to allow Ukraine to indiscriminately attack Russia at this time, this could create the rational for overwhelming retaliation on the part of Russia, including the possible use of nuclear warheads, albeit only tactical. This is possibly why the US is still restricting Ukraine from attacking Moscow. ( i wish I didn’t have to go through this explanation). You should also be able to appreciate that no country,or enen alliance, is able to attack so many international constraints on any given moment. Either you are strategic and choose or you don’t have a chance of success!

Finally, I receive many comments from people who fumble in their texts. I choose not to engage with them on the quality of their wording. Why? Because I constantly wish to show respect for the persons and for expressing their opinions rather than focus on form. Otherwise,I could be degrading their substantive views by doing so. I could have sent you the same text in French without the blink of an eye! And nobody should say that I am lucky. We choose.

François

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts